Brazil's Slaves Are Being Freed – But Are Its Slaveholders Being Punished?
I bought Francisco Lima his first taste of freedom in decades.
It was 2004, and Brazil was starting to confront one of its most distressing problems: slavery. I was in northern Pará state, in the Amazon, observing a special police unit that raided slave-holding farms and firms and liberated workers like the 74-year-old Lima.
We found Lima in a squalid, dirt-floor shack with bees buzzing over his pot of days-old rice and beans. The cops brought him to a nearby town, and a colleague and I invited him to lunch. Lima seemed lost in the diner and said he’d have whatever we were having. When his cheeseburger arrived, he furrowed his brow and asked, “Como a gente come isto?”
"How do you eat this?"
That’s when I realized just how long Lima had been a slave – almost a quarter century by his recollection. Since well before cheeseburgers had made their way onto menus in the Amazon.
Ten years later, is Brazil – a new economic powerhouse that considers itself on the brink of development – doing enough to make sure powerless lives like Lima’s are no longer being stolen?
Yes and no.
As slavery-busting teams like the one I accompanied demonstrate, the South American giant has in many ways become a model for addressing a tragedy that still plagues the entire world. In the past 20 years, almost 50,000 enslaved Brazilian workers have been freed from some 2,000 worksites, from cattle ranches to charcoal plants for pig-iron production. Since 2004, a national lista suja, or “dirty list,” has fingered some 300 guilty companies, making it hard for them to get financing.
“We are ahead on this,” says Leonardo Sakamoto, president of Repórter Brasil, a São Paulo-based anti-slavery group. “I believe that Brazil has a model, and [it’s] considered by the International Labour Organization as an example [of] the fight against slavery.”
But activists like Sakamato also recognize that the fight is seriously undermined by Brazil’s deep-seated impunity. Slaveholders can pay hefty fines and civil damages, but criminal convictions and jail time are rare.
As a result, says Karen Stauss, programs director for Free the Slaves in Washington, D.C. – which on Thursday, Jan. 30, will co-host a human trafficking conference with Broward College in Davie – an estimated 200,000 people are still trapped in slavery in Brazil.
“People are coming out of slavery, but it's a revolving door,” Stauss says, “As one person comes out, because the slaveholder is not really punished, a new person goes in.”
That could change this year. Brazil is moving closer to final passage of a constitutional amendment that would hit slave-holders where it hurts them most: confiscation of their property – all of it.
People are coming out of slavery, but it's a revolving door. As one person comes out, because the slaveholder is not really punished, a new person goes in.
Yet that measure, which has been debated for more than a decade now, keeps getting held up. To understand why, it helps first to appreciate why Brazil has the western hemisphere’s worst slavery situation in the first place.
Brazil was the hemisphere’s last country to abolish slavery, in 1888. Afterward, social and economic inequality remained so severe that slavery itself continued to be acceptable – albeit in more deceptive forms.
The most common is debt bondage.
Brazil’s urban middle class has grown significantly this century, but rural poverty is still harsh, and laborers are often lured far from home by promises of good jobs. Once many arrive, however, they’re shackled by bogus but insurmountable debts for travel, food, clothes and tools. Hence those workers never get paid – and too often, like Lima, they never escape.
Sakamoto, who will speak at this week’s Broward College forum, recalls the first time he came upon indentured farm hands in Pará.
“We found 52 workers in very, very bad conditions,” says Sakamoto, “living in [the] jungle, in barracks, people that [were left] to die with disease, hunting to eat, drinking terrible water.”
In response to such scenes, groups like Repórter Brasil, as well as the Roman Catholic Church’s Pastoral Land Commission, have convinced Brazil’s government and private sectors to sign on to instruments like the Slave Eradication Pact. That association now includes companies that represent 30 percent of Brazil’s $2.3 trillion GDP.
Those firms have not only renounced slavery; they’ve pledged not to do business with anyone else who practices it. That in turn has convinced foreign businesses that operate in or buy from Brazil, like U.S. automakers, to follow suit.
“That ability to reach into the supply chain is unique in Brazil,” says Stauss. “The Brazilian government in collaboration with civil society is definitely a model element.”
Still, the element that’s missing is real deterrence – especially the constitutional amendment, which Brazil’s ultra-powerful farming and ranching lobby keeps finding ways to block. Until it’s unchained, Brazil may be a model – but only half a model.
Tim Padgett is WLRN's Americas editor. You can read more of his coverage here.