Trump's Pandemic Response Has Conservative High Schooler Turning Towards Biden

May 27, 2020

The 2020 presidential election campaign has already been a rollercoaster ride for Jacob Cuenca.

As of early March, the 18-year-old high school senior in Homestead, a city just south of Miami, was an avowed Republican who planned to cast his first vote this November for President Donald Trump.

But three months into the coronavirus pandemic, that clearsightedness has started to shift. 

In these uncertain times, you can rely on WLRN to keep you current on local news and information. Your support is what keeps WLRN strong. Please become a member today. Donate Now. Thank you.

Trump’s response to the pandemic has not lived up to Cuenca’s expectations. It’s a case study in how first-time voters are weathering the political, economic and social upheavals brought about by the spread of COVID-19.

“Supposedly the administration knew about the coronavirus for a couple of months but didn’t warn, like, the population or something,” Cuenca said this month. “He just didn’t handle it right.”

Cuenca is now considering voting for former Vice President Joe Biden, the presumptive Democratic nominee.

In a swing state as important as Florida, decisions made by young Latino voters like Cuenca could determine the outcome of the entire election. Key statewide races have been decided by a margin of 1 percent or less. As the state’s Latino population has boomed, it has been aggressively courted by both Republicans and Democrats.

Even before the pandemic, Cuenca said, his support for Trump in the 2020 election was somewhat reluctant. 

Next week, Cuenca will graduate from MAST Academy, a public high school in Miami that sits on the coast and specializes in marine science studies. His teachers there have emphasized the impact of sea-level rise and climate change on Florida’s ecosystems. 

“Trump, he says some nonsense, and honestly, I really don't agree with a lot of things he does like, building the wall or how he thinks climate change is fake and all this stuff,” Cuenca said.

Still, Cuenca said, he identifies as a conservative at heart — and it goes beyond Trump.

“I just believe in conservatism,” Cuenca said in early March. “I feel like you can achieve everything just by working hard enough. As long as you set your mind to it and you have a dream and that glare in your eyes, you can do whatever you want, honestly. You really can.”

“You can't let one person ruin the whole entire party,” he added.

CONSERVATIVE VALUES

Cuenca’s Mexican American mother is a Democrat. But his father is a Cuban American who voted for Trump and leans more conservative. Growing up, Cuenca heard horror stories of Cuba’s leftist government from his paternal grandfather, who was a political prisoner on the island.

“He fled from Cuba. He refused communism two times and got thrown in jail,” Cuenca said of his grandfather. “They put him for like nine years to work in the sugar cane fields.”

But politically, Cuenca said he came to view himself as a conservative on his own. He credits an AP American History course and a habit of reading news articles from a variety of sources.

“I just feel like I fell more in line with the conservative values than I do the liberal values,” Cuenca said. He believes in low taxes for the wealthy and a limited welfare state. Even so, he hold some more liberal-aligned positions, like support for abortion rights.

Tristan, left, and Jacob Cuenca in their neighborhood in Homestead, Florida, on May 21, 2020.
Credit Jayme Gershen for The World

Looks-wise, Cuenca is more 1990s than 2020. He’s a massive fan of the band Nirvana. The first time we met, he had an Incesticide album cover t-shirt.

“I wanna say he’s the embodiment of a rebellious teenager,” said Tristan, Cuenca’s older brother. “He kind of has that Kurt Cobain look to him, the blonde hair, listening to a lot of grunge music. A lot of alternative stuff. And it’s very funny.”

Cuenca’s favorite Nirvana song is “Radio Friendly Unit Shifter” from the In Utero album. In it, Kurt Cobain interrogates himself about why he alternates between this and that, hot and cold. “What is wrong with me?” the song asks.

DECIDING BETWEEN TWO CANDIDATES

Lately, Cuenca is interrogating himself, too.

“Especially when it comes to politics, recently when I’ve heard my brother speak about certain things I’m like, Jacob has been doing his research into all this stuff,” Tristan said. “He’s kind of going through that phase of not flip-flopping, but weighing the pros and cons of both sides.”

Nearly three months into the coronavirus pandemic, Cuenca is still weighing the pros and cons of both political parties in the lead-up to the 2020 presidential election. And some differences are starting to show.

“My dad’s hours have gotten cut. So that’s something that’s kind of scary,” Cuenca said. 

The economy has bottomed out for a huge segment of the population, while the U.S. leads the world in deaths and cases of COVID-19. Florida has registered more than 50,000 cases and more than 2,000 deaths related to the novel coronavirus, according to the Florida Department of Health. 

Cuenca has never been a fan of Biden. 

“I would not vote for him,” he said in March. 

Cuenca considered voting for then-presidential candidate Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, whose proposals and message to youth Cuenca found “inspiring," even as he found them "far fetched and unrealistic." "His message just speaks to the youth," said Cuenca. "My people, my generation."

Sanders has since ended his campaign. 

That put Cuenca squarely in the Trump camp, until the socioeconomic damage of the pandemic hit and became personal.

Now, Cuenca finds himself torn between who he sees as two candidates he calls “incompetent:” Biden and Trump. 

The history of how social programs from President Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s New Deal helped lift the nation out of the Great Depression weighs heavily on his mind. Cuenca recently read about this history in his classes.

“The Democrat always helps the little people, the people who are like losing their jobs,” Cuenca said. “So I think right now — I don’t know. I kind of think I’d rather vote for Biden than Trump at this point.”

This story is part of "Every 30 Seconds," a collaborative public media reporting project tracing the young Latino electorate leading up to the 2020 presidential election and beyond.