The Power Of Martin Luther King Jr.'s Anger

Feb 20, 2019
Originally published on March 7, 2019 12:37 pm

When Martin Luther King, Jr. was in high school, he won an oratorical contest sponsored by the Negro Elks. He and a beloved teacher were returning home in triumph, riding on a bus, when some white passengers got on. The white bus driver ordered King and his teacher to give up their seats, and cursed them. King wanted to stay seated, but his teacher urged him to obey the law. They had to stand in the aisle for the 90 miles back to Atlanta, Ga.

"That night will never leave my memory," King told an interviewer, decades later. "It was the angriest I have ever been in my life."

All this month, NPR is exploring the power of anger. And King is an example of someone who showed a kind of genius for turning that emotion into positive action.

"My father was extremely angry from that incident. So much so that he expressed it later on by saying that he came very dangerously close, at that particular time, to hating all white people," says Bernice King, who now runs The King Center in Atlanta.

As he grew older, and went to college and theological school, Martin Luther King, Jr. realized that non-violent resistance offered a way to channel anger into positive forms of protest. "If you internalize anger, and you don't find a channel, it can destroy you," she says. "That's why when Daddy reiterated, 'Hate is too great a burden to bear,' he knew it was corrosive and erosive."

Though King became an icon of non-violence and peace, he also inwardly wrestled with anger and, at times, would snap at those he loved. Looking at how King dealt with anger reveals its dual nature—how it can be a motivating force for change, while also containing the potential for destruction.

When he was a young child, seeing his father's anger had a real impact on King. Once, a white sales clerk told his father that they had to move to the back of a shoe store, rather than being waited on in the front of the shop. "Whereupon he took me by the hand and walked out of the store. This was the first time I had seen Dad so furious," King later recalled, in a collection of writings called The Autobiography of Martin Luther King, Jr.

"That experience revealed to me at a very early age that my father had not adjusted to the system, and he played a great part in shaping my conscience," noted King.

King was only 26 years old when he was thrust into a leadership role in the struggle for civil rights. Rosa Parks had just been arrested in Montgomery, Alabama, where King was working as a preacher. King found himself having to speak before thousands of people who had gathered in a mass meeting at the Holt Street Baptist Church—and those people were upset.

"How could I make a speech that would be militant enough to keep my people aroused to positive action and yet moderate enough to keep this fervor within controllable and Christian bounds?" King later wrote. "What could I say to keep them courageous and prepared for positive action and yet devoid of hate and resentment? Could the militant and the moderate be combined in a single speech?"

He told the crowd that the only weapon they would use was the weapon of protest—that they would follow the teachings of Jesus.

Their resolve was soon tested when someone threw dynamite at King's house. He rushed home to find that a crowd of his supporters had gathered, and some had weapons. His wife, Coretta Scott King, later wrote in her book My Life, My Love, My Legacy that the atmosphere "was so rife with tension that if a black man had tripped over a white man, it could have set off a riot."

King calmly stood on his front porch, told everyone to go home, and spoke about loving your enemies. "It was a really noble moment," says David Garrow, a historian who wrote a biography of King. "Most people would be expressing very intense anger, and he was utterly to the contrary."

In private, though, King struggled. He later recalled that that night, he lay awake in bed thinking that his wife and baby could have been killed by the blast. He wrote, "I could feel the anger rising." But then he caught himself, and thought, "You must not allow yourself to become bitter."

"He deeply believed in something that almost sounds silly, that almost sounds trite, but he really believed in the power of redemptive love," says Clarence Jones, who worked as an attorney and speechwriter for King.

"From Dr. King's standpoint, anger is part of a process that includes anger, forgiveness, redemption and love," explains Jones. "Because if you only have anger, the anger will paralyze you. You cannot do anything constructive."

In 1963, Jones went to see King in jail, in Birmingham, Alabama. Jones was hoping to talk about how to raise bail for the imprisoned protesters, but King was preoccupied with a full-page ad that he had seen in the local newspaper. It was an open letter written by the local white clergymen, and it said King should leave the city. It didn't have a word about the injustice of segregation.

"So he was very angry," recalls Jones.

King's response, initially scribbled on the scraps of paper he had in his cell, is the famous Letter from a Birmingham Jail. His anger propelled him to write one of the most powerful pieces of persuasive writing ever. He passionately explained the principles of non-violent protest and the righteous, justifiable anger of African-Americans.

That's not to say King never just showed irritation or snapped at people. He was, after all, human.

"Yes, he got angry with people he worked with. But the anger was in the context of respect and love," says Jones. He says King's anger was often more like a disappointment that people had misunderstood what his expectations were or weren't meeting them.

Those episodes became more common in the last months of his life, after years of nonstop tension and work, says Garrow.

"There were a number of occasions where King expressed irritation at close friends and staff members," says Garrow, noting that King was apparently depressed, exhausted, and drinking a lot.

King's close companion, Ralph Abernathy, has written that on the day he was assassinated, King argued with a female friend, lost his temper, and knocked her across a hotel room bed.

"It was more of a shove than a real blow, but for a short man, Martin had a prodigious strength that always surprised me," Abernathy wrote in his autobiography, And the Walls Came Tumbling Down. "She leapt up to fight back, and for a moment they were engaged in a full- blown fight, with Martin clearly winning. Then it was all over."

Many found it shocking to think that King could be physically abusive to anyone, and Abernathy was widely criticized for telling this story.

In an interview with C-SPAN before he died, Abernathy said that King would have wanted him to be honest. "Jesus was a nonviolent personality," noted Abernathy, "but Jesus became violent on one occasion when he ran the people out of the temple."

Clayborne Carson, director of the Martin Luther King Jr. Research and Education Institute at Stanford University, says he doesn't know if this account about King is true.

"But I do recognize that a Martin Luther King can be angry. It would surprise me if that were not the case," says Carson. "I have no doubt that he got mad. There were many things for him to get mad at. He felt sometimes betrayed by other people. He felt the same kind of impatience that other people felt with the pace of change. All of these things would anger him."

He says King learned how to use that anger productively. "You could be angry that the system that is oppressing you, but try not to direct that anger towards people who were caught up in that system," says Carson.

During the bus boycott in Montgomery, for example, King did occasionally lose his cool with white officials—and quickly regretted it. "I was weighed down by a terrible sense of guilt, remembering that on two or three occasions I had allowed myself to become angry and indignant," King wrote. "I had spoken hastily and resentfully. Yet I knew that this was no way to solve a problem...you must be willing to suffer the anger of the opponent, and yet not return anger."

This, he knew, was not always easy. Later, after he had become famous,King had an advice column in Ebony magazine. Someone once asked, "How can I overcome my bad temper? When I am angry, I say things to those I love that hurt them terribly."

King replied that the letter-writer had made an important first step by admitting this weakness. "You should also seek to concentrate on the higher virtue of calmness. You expel a lower vice by concentrating on a higher virtue," King explained. "A destructive passion is harnessed by directing that same passion into constructive channels."

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

Martin Luther King Jr. came to embody the ideal of peaceful, nonviolent protest. So how did he handle his anger? All this month, NPR has been examining anger to see what we can learn from this powerful emotion. Today NPR's Nell Greenfieldboyce looks at the anger of someone who showed a kind of genius for turning that emotion into positive action.

NELL GREENFIELDBOYCE, BYLINE: In 1963, 34-year-old Martin Luther King Jr. was in jail in Birmingham, Ala. His attorney Clarence Jones wanted to talk about bail, but King was preoccupied.

CLARENCE JONES: And I said, Martin, did you hear what I said? He said, but have you seen this? And I said, what's this? And he picked up the Birmingham Herald and showed me a copy of a full-page ad.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: It was an open letter written by the local white clergymen saying King should leave the city. It didn't have a word about the injustice of segregation.

JONES: So he was very angry.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

MARTIN LUTHER KING JR: My dear fellow clergymen, while confined here in the Birmingham City Jail, I came across your recent statement calling my present activities unwise and untimely.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: This is King reading the response he scribbled on scraps of paper - the famous "Letter from Birmingham Jail" in which he said injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

KING JR: There comes a time when the cup of endurance runs over, and men are no longer willing to be plunged into the abyss of despair.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: Growing up, King felt that despair and anger. When he was in high school, he won an oratorical contest. He and a beloved teacher were coming home on a bus. The white driver told them to give up their seats to white passengers and cursed them. They stood in the aisle for the 90 miles back to Atlanta. Decades later, King said that was the angriest he had ever been in his life. His daughter Bernice King runs The King Center in Atlanta.

BERNICE KING: My father was extremely angry from that incident. So much so that he expressed it later on by saying that he came very, dangerously close at that particular time to hating all white people.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: In college and theological school, her father learned about nonviolent resistance. He realized it offered a productive way to channel anger that could otherwise destroy someone.

KING: That's why when daddy reiterated hate is too great a burden to bear, he knew that it was corrosive and erosive.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: Martin Luther King Jr. was only 26 years old when he was thrust into a leadership role in civil rights. Rosa Parks had just been arrested in Montgomery, Ala., where he was working as a preacher. King spoke before huge crowds appealing to people's emotions so that they'd rise up and boycott public buses while simultaneously not letting all the anger get out of control.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

KING JR: Today I'm not here advocating violence.

(CROSSTALK)

GREENFIELDBOYCE: Instead of using violence like the Ku Klux Klan, they would follow the teachings of Jesus. During the year-long boycott, someone threw dynamite at his house. He rushed home to find a crowd of his supporters who were almost ready to riot. He calmly stood on his porch and spoke about loving your enemies.

DAVID GARROW: And it was a really noble moment.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: David Garrow is a historian who wrote a biography of King.

GARROW: Most people would be, you know, expressing very intense anger. And he was, utterly, to the contrary.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: In private, he struggled. King later recalled that, that night, he lay awake in bed thinking that his wife and baby could have been killed. He wrote, quote, "I could feel the anger rising." Clarence Jones says, for King, anger was always part of a process that ended in forgiveness.

JONES: He deeply believed in something that almost sounds silly - that almost sounds trite. But he really believed in the power of redemptive love.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: That's not to say he never showed irritation or snapped at people, especially in the last months of his life. After years of nonstop tension and work, his close companion, Ralph Abernathy, has written that on the day he was assassinated, King argued with a female friend and even shoved her across a hotel room bed. Abernathy was criticized for saying that. But in an interview with C-SPAN before he died, Abernathy said, look, Jesus was nonviolent.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

RALPH ABERNATHY: But Jesus became violent on one occasion when he ran the people out of the temple.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: I asked Clayborne Carson if he believed this story about King. He's director of the Martin Luther King, Jr., Research and Education Institute at Stanford University.

CLAYBORNE CARSON: You know, I wasn't there, so I can't judge. But I do recognize that a Martin Luther King can be angry. It would surprise me if that were not the case.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: King once told his congregation that people will inevitably fail to perfectly live out all of their ideals, but what mattered was the effort.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

KING JR: Get somebody to be able to say about you, he may not have reached the highest height; he may not have realized all of his dreams, but he tried.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: For a while, King had an advice column in Ebony magazine. Someone once asked, how can I overcome my bad temper; when I'm angry, I say things to those I love that hurt them terribly. King replied, quote, "a destructive passion is harnessed by directing that same passion into constructive channels." Nell Greenfieldboyce, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.